A Study of Partitioning Policies for Graph Analytics on Large-scale Distributed Platforms

(Download publication here) (Download slides here) (Download source code here)

Abstract

Distributed-memory clusters are used for in-memory processing of very large graphs with billions of nodes and edges. This requires partitioning the graph among the machines in the cluster. When a graph is partitioned, a node in the graph may be replicated on several machines, and communication is required to keep these replicas synchronized. Good partitioning policies attempt to reduce this synchronization overhead while keeping the computational load balanced across machines. A number of recent studies have looked at ways to control replication of nodes, but these studies are not conclusive because they were performed on small clusters with eight to sixteen machines, did not consider work-efficient data-driven algorithms, or did not optimize communication for the partitioning strategies they studied.

This paper presents an experimental study of partitioning strategies for work-efficient graph analytics applications on large KNL and Skylake clusters with up to 256 machines using the Gluon communication runtime which implements partitioning-specific communication optimizations. Evaluation results show that although simple partitioning strategies like Edge-Cuts perform well on a small number of machines, an alternative partitioning strategy called Cartesian Vertex-Cut (CVC) performs better at scale even though paradoxically it has a higher replication factor and performs more communication than Edge-Cut partitioning does. Results from communication micro-benchmarks resolve this paradox by showing that communication overhead depends not only on communication volume but also on the communication pattern among the partitions.

These experiments suggest that high-performance graph analytics systems should support multiple partitioning strategies, like Gluon does, as no single graph partitioning strategy is best for all cluster sizes. For such systems, a decision tree for selecting a good partitioning strategy based on characteristics of the computation and the cluster is presented.